How safe are we as healthcare providers?

Being a healthcare provider has always come with personal risk. We care for all patients, which includes patients agitated due to psychiatric issues, dementia, acute medical illness, alcohol or drug intoxication, or simply anger. Patients can be extremely volatile and lash out unexpectedly, causing physical injury to their doctor, nurse, or other provider. Besides the physical risk, patients can be emotionally and verbally abusive as well- both types of violence take their toll. Workplace violence is on the rise and OSHA reports indicate that only 70% of violent encounters are ever reported upwards to a supervisor. The NEJM published a review article last year on workplace violence calling it a “problem that had been tolerated and largely ignored”. Healthcare has the highest incidence of workplace violence outside of law enforcement.
Recently the dangers of patients unhappy and dissatisfied with their care, particularly as it pertains to obtaining controlled substances, have been making the news. This danger has been increasingly apparent since we as providers have been scaling back on prescriptions of controlled substances, but reports of abusive opioid seeking patients were readily available years ago ( A most extreme example recently occurred in Indiana where a patient’s husband shot and killed her doctor for not giving her an opiate prescription (,amp.html). This was the first time the patient had seen this physician, and this single patient encounter led to his death. Several years ago, another irate patient in Kentucky murdered his doctor for not prescribing him opiates- he was sentenced to 40 years in prison ( Both these physicians were killed for practicing good medicine, and this is a heartbreaking, frightening reality.
As we as a medical community continue to grapple with the risk of workplace violence, is there anything that we as individual providers can help to prevent protect ourselves? I would offer the following:
1. Be clear immediately and up front with the patient what his or her expectations should be. Many PCP offices have instituted policies where they never prescribe controlled substances, or at least never on the first visit. Knowing this information as soon as possible, ideally before the appointment, can help to diffuse the tension or lead the patient to seek care elsewhere.
2. In the hospital setting, there are on call police and security teams and special codes to raise the alert for violent patients and trigger a response team- know what your policies are! In the office where this response team is usually not possible, have a clear safety plan in place with your staff and a pre-planned method to alert them to your situation.
3. Be alert to the risk of violence before you enter the room. Has the patient been violent in the past? Do they have mental health, addiction, or chronic pain issues that place them at a higher risk for violent behavior? Consider tagging patients’ medical records to alert the staff of the risk for violence. If you know that risk is present, do not go into the patient’s room unattended.
4. Either in the hospital or office setting, when a patient starts to become agitated and violent, do the following: a. speak softly and do not raise your voice b. listen actively and maintain positive nonverbal communication with eye contact and nodding c. acknowledge that you can see the patient is frustrated and upset d. reassure the patient you are listening to his or her concerns e. let the patient talk without interrupting them f. ask what you can do to help resolve the issue
5. If you sense the situation is going to escalate, and cannot be resolved, move slowly toward the exit. Keep as much physical distance between yourself and the patient as possible. Alert the surrounding staff and call the police as soon as is feasible.
6. Report any violent encounter according to your hospital or clinic protocol.
7. Talk to your administrators about workplace violence policies that are in place or under development at your hospital or practice.
Violence in our workplace is an ongoing issue. We can each help by reporting all violent incidents as they occur, and having firm policies and procedures in place.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: